Skip to content
Browse articles

A Study of the Un-Paninian Verb-forms in the Critical Edition of the Adiparvan of the Mahabharata

By Harendra Chandra Sil

Vol. 36 · No. 1March - 1960pp. 35–57English

Summary

In this substantial linguistic study, Harendra Chandra Sil examines hundreds of non‑Pāṇinian verb forms in the Critical Edition of the Ādiparvan of the Mahābhārata. The Ādiparvan, the epic’s opening book, is linguistically conservative and preserves forms that deviate from Pāṇini’s standardised Sanskrit. Sil focuses on the augmentless imperfect—a preterite form that omits the augment ‘a’—and categorises the examples found. He distinguishes between augmentless imperfects without change of voice, with change of voice, with change of conjugation, and with change of both conjugation and voice. Numerous examples are cited, and the author analyses their metre and context. He then surveys augmentless aorists, passive forms with active endings, and other anomalous constructions. The paper argues that many of these “irregular” forms result from metrical considerations in verses or from the influence of Prakrit and older dialects. Sil notes that the critical editors often emend these forms to fit Pāṇinian norms, but he cautions that doing so erases linguistic evidence for archaic usage. Future and conditional verb forms are also discussed; the author shows that the confusion between active and middle endings in some futures may reflect mixed paradigms rather than scribal errors. The article concludes that the Ādiparvan preserves strata of language predating classical Sanskrit and that studying such forms can illuminate the historical development of Sanskrit grammar. Sil’s systematic classification of the verb forms and his concordance of examples provide a valuable reference for philologists. He calls for more studies of non‑Pāṇinian usages in other parts of the epic and in Vedic literature to trace the evolution of verbal morphology.

AI-generated summary, automatically checked against the article text.

Conclusion

Harendra Chandra Sil’s analysis demonstrates that many aberrant verb forms in the Ādiparvan are not mistakes but survivals of pre‑Pāṇinian verbal systems. By classifying augmentless imperfects and aorists and examining future forms with mismatched endings, he shows that the epic reflects a transitional stage between Vedic and classical Sanskrit. These findings caution editors against normalising texts according to later grammatical rules and invite scholars to use such forms as evidence for linguistic change. The study enriches our understanding of the Mahābhārata’s composition and of the history of Sanskrit morphology.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “Loss of augment in the imperfect in the Adiparvan 15 mainly metri causa, about one-third of the cases occurring owing to dilambic close; but there are also cases which are not metri causa.”
  • “The perfect-system in the Adiparvan of the Mahabharata consists only of an indicative tense and a participle—both of them in the two voices, active and middle”

Works cited in this article

  1. Macdonell, 413b
  2. Edgerton, 32. 2-4
  3. Geiger, 5 158
  4. Pischel, §515
  5. Whitney's Roots

Discussed in this article

People

Texts & works

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

A Study of the un-Paninian Verb-forms in the Critical Edition of the Adiparvan of the Mahabharata

By Harendra Chandra Sil

March - 1961