Skip to content
Browse articles

A Note on a remark of Yuan Chwang

By Ramashankar Tripathi

Vol. 8 · No. 1March - 1932pp. 113–116English
Epigraphic Evidence Analysis

Summary

Tripathi addresses a statement by the Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang (Yuan Chwang) concerning a supposed six‑year reign of a certain Indian king. Previous historians have interpreted Xuanzang’s remark to refer to Harṣavardhana, leading to chronological confusion. Tripathi re‑examines the Chinese sources and cross‑checks them with Indian inscriptions. He argues that Xuanzang actually referred to the reign of Śrīharṣa of Malwa, a minor ruler, and that translators misread Chinese numerals. The article clarifies the timeline of early seventh‑century Indian rulers and underscores the need for philological accuracy when using Chinese travel accounts. Tripathi also explores the political circumstances of the period, including alliances and conflicts among the Maukhari, Gāhaḍavāla, and Chalukya powers.

AI-assisted summary, not yet checked. Consult the original PDF before citing.

Conclusion

Tripathi concludes that careful textual analysis can resolve chronological puzzles. His reassessment of Xuanzang’s remark removes an anomaly in the accepted chronology of north Indian kings and demonstrates the value of correlating Chinese accounts with indigenous evidence.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “The remark of Yuan Chwang that Ilarsa ‘“waged incessant warfare antil in six years he had fought the Five Indias {according to another reading he had brought the 101૪૦ Indias under 0112912306)” ',! has fed some scliolars to the view that all conquests of Harga “૪૦૯ over by about A.D. 612, that he had become king six vears earlier (the period of the vonguest) in A.D. 606.” and that “Harsa’s wars with Valabhi and T'ulakedi took place within A.D. 612"”
  • “There is no basis for supposing {liat Yuan Chwong's ‘six years’ began in 000 A.D., the year of Hursa’s accession, and ended in 612 A.D. 7१५ implies It would involve a discrepancy, since the lerm “Five lndias sovereignty over (Gauda and Orissu also, but the Ganjam inscription® shows that his invelerate enemy Sudinks wus fourshing 18 these regions as late 85 the year 019 A.D.”
  • “It would thus be evident from the foregoing discussion that we have: no ground to support the theory that all the warlike activities of Harsu ““were over hy 000101 A.D. 612.””

Works cited in this article

  1. Watters, 1, p. 343
  2. Beal, 1, p. 213
  3. C. V. Vaidya, HMHI, I, p. 13
  4. Hevell's Aryan Rule in India, p. 1915
  5. EI, रण, ¥I, 141

Discussed in this article

People

Places

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by Ramashankar Tripathi

All articles →
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Review: Buddha Purva Ka Bharatiya Itihasa (Part I)

By Ramashankar Tripathi

Deceber - 1942
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Alexander's Invasion of India: a revised Study

By Ramashankar Tripathi

September - 1940
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Religious Toleration under the Imperial Guptas

By Ramashankar Tripathi

March - 1939
The Indian Historical Quarterly

The Pratihara Administration

By Ramashankar Tripathi

March - 1933

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

The Antiquity of Pandharpur

By Bhaskar Anand Saletore

December - 1935
The Indian Historical Quarterly

The Rise of Vijayanagara

By Bhaskar Anand Saletore

December - 1932
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Adisura

By Pramode Lal Paul

March - 1935
Journal of Indian History and Culture

Iron Artisans and Village Life in Early Orissa (400-1000 AD)

By R. C. Misra

March 1997
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Origin of the Pratihara Dynasty

By D. R. Mankad

September - 1934