Skip to content
Browse articles

Reviews

By U. N. Ghoshal, Kaccayana, Arthur Berriedale Keith, Bimala Charan Law

Vol. 1 · No. 3September - 1925pp. 581–590English

Summary

This section of the journal offers reviews of recent books in Indology. Louis de la Vallée Poussin’s ‘Nirvāṇa’ synthesises previous scholarship on the Buddhist notion of liberation and, for the first time, systematically relates the Mahāyāna concept to its early Buddhist roots. The reviewer praises Poussin’s clarity but notes that the book does not fully trace the intermediary stages between the Pāli canon and later philosophy. Other reviews cover Indian M. C. A. B. L. Hon. D.’s ‘The Buddha and Hell in Buddhist Perspective’, which places the doctrine of hell in the context of compassion and karma, and J. Takakusu’s ‘A Concise Dictionary of Buddhist Terms’, commended for its philological rigour. There are critical notices of a French translation of the Bhagavad Gītā and of an edition of the Somadeva’s Kathāsaritsāgara. Each review summarises the work’s aims, evaluates its methodology, and situates it within current research. Together they illustrate the growing international exchange of ideas on Buddhism and Sanskrit literature. The section reflects the journal’s commitment to informing readers about new resources while maintaining scholarly standards.

AI-assisted summary, not yet checked. Consult the original PDF before citing.

Conclusion

The review section demonstrates that critical engagement with both Indian and Western scholarship is essential for advancing understanding. By highlighting strengths and weaknesses, the reviewer guides readers toward reliable resources and fosters rigorous debate.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “18 Vallde Poussin has not only assimilated the labours of his predecessors, but has outshone them 10 one particalar respect, viz., the possibility his researches have opened एफ of supply- ing a historical basis of Nirvana as it is understood by the “Nihilists” _ and the “Positivists®.”
  • “the essential fact remains that for the average Buddhists, as for the average Brahmin, action was dominated by the expecta- tion of bliss and the fear of pain; Nirvipa and the absolute were abstractions for the philosophically minded alone to care for.”

Works cited in this article

  1. NIRVANA—Par Louis de la Vallée Poussin. Gabriel Beauchesne, Editeur A Paris, Rue et Rennes, 117. 1925. 8૦. pp. i-xxiii, 1-194.
  2. HEAVEN AND HELL IN BUDDHIST PERSPECTIVE, By Dr. Bimala Charan Law, M. A, B. L., Ph. D,, with a foreword by the Earl of Ronaldshay, P. C
  3. THE INDO-SUMERIAN SEALS DECIPHERED. By 1. A. Waddell, LL. D, C. B, C. 1. Luzac & Co., London. (925. pp. xxiv+ 146.
  4. Sir John Marshall's articles in the 27/57/72 Lonion News of the 201 September, 1924

Discussed in this article

People

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 1 · No. 3
406–414Two Copperplate Charters of the Haihaya king Prthvideva II of the Cedi years 900 and 905Hiralal Jain415–422Date of KaniskaR. Kimura422–428DharmasamuccayaDharmaditya Dharmacharya429–432Surunga and the Kautiliya ArthasastraMaurice Winternitz433–442Magadhi Prakrit and BengaliMuhammad Shahidullah443–456Will in Early Buddhist ScripturesC. A. F. Rhys Davids456–463Rasitala or the Under‑worldNandu Lal Dey464–472The Northern BuddhismHariprasad G. Shastri473–482A Problem of Ancient South Indian HistoryK. G. Sesha Aiyar483–489The Evidence of Panini on Vasudeva‑WorshipUmesh Chandra Bhattacharya489–500Politics and Political History in the MahabharataNarayan Chandra Banerji501–517Pali, the Language of the Southern BuddhistsArthur Berriedale Keith518–522Bhati Rajputs — The Modern Representatives of the Indo‑Bactrian Rulers of Kabul and Northern PunjabKunwar Shivnath Singh Sengar522–532Ministers in Ancient IndiaRadha Govinda Basak532–537SelihotraGirindranath Mukherji537–539Inscription on the Pedestal of a newly found Visnu ImageHaridas Mitra539–544Indian Literature AbroadPrabhat Kumar Mukherji545–560Hindu Politics in ItalianHaridas Mitra561–565The Andhras and the TelugusM. Venkataramayya565–566Report of the Archaeological Department, Hyderabad StateC. S. Srinivasachari566–568Sankaracarya CaritamK. Rama Pisharoti569–570A Note on the Word KautalyaV. Venkatarama Sharma570–577Hindu Imperial Systems and Mr. K. P. Jayaswal577–578Hindu Theories of the Origin of Kingship and Mr. K. P. Jayaswal—A Supplement578–580The Punjab Sanskrit SeriesD. Bhattacharya581–590ReviewsU. N. Ghoshal, Kaccayana, Arthur Berriedale Keith, Bimala Charan LawCurrent article591–594Select Contents of Oriental JournalsU. N. Ghoshal595–598Obituary NoticeB. M. Barua

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by U. N. Ghoshal

All articles →
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Two aspects of Law and Politics in the Indian State

By U. N. Ghoshal

Mar-58
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Review: Caulukyas of Gujarat

By U. N. Ghoshal

March - 1957
The Indian Historical Quarterly

The Purana Stories of Vena and Prithu and their Philosophical Significance

By U. N. Ghoshal

December - 1956
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Principle of the King's Righteousness

By U. N. Ghoshal

June & September 1956

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

Tattva-Jijnasa (Review)

By Nalinaksha Dutt

December - 1951
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review: New Documents of Jaina Painting

By Paresh Chandra Dasgupta

April 1976
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review – S. A. Jain: Reality

By Satya Ranjan Banerjee

October - 1993
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review – India & Indology

April - 1979
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Reviews

By Kalidas Nag, A. B. M. Habibullah, Arthur Berriedale Keith

March - 1938
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review: Purana Perennis

By Satya Ranjan Banerjee

January - 1994