Skip to content
Browse articles

Caste System's Enduring Grip: Historical Roots and British Reinforcement

By Nanditha C. Krishna

Vol. 28December 2021pp. 515–520English
British colonial impact

Summary

The caste system in India has evolved significantly over time, with historical flexibility and fluidity in social identities. Early texts like the Rig Veda do not mention caste, while the Purusha sukta introduces the four varna system, which does not align with the complex jatis that developed. Historical examples, such as Valmiki, Hemu, and Shivaji, demonstrate how individuals transcended caste boundaries based on merit and leadership. The British colonial period rigidified caste through policies like the English Education Act of 1835, which promoted Western learning and institutionalized caste divisions. The census further entrenched these divisions by categorizing jatis into varnas, despite pre-colonial flexibility. Caste permeated religious and social spheres, influencing identities in Islam and Christianity. Despite urbanization and education, caste remains entrenched in rural areas, with Dalits facing discrimination and violence. The author expresses concern over the persistent relevance of caste in modern politics and society, questioning when India will move toward treating all individuals as equals.

AI-assisted summary, not yet checked. Consult the original PDF before citing.

Conclusion

The document highlights the persistent influence of the caste system in India despite historical fluidity and modernization, emphasizing its reinforcement through British colonial policies. It underscores how caste, once more flexible and less rigidly defined in pre-colonial times, became entrenched through British administrative practices like census categorization and the promotion of rigid social hierarchies. The author notes the enduring discrimination faced by marginalized communities, including Dalits, and the irony of caste permeating even religious institutions. While urbanization offers hope for social mixing, rural areas remain marked by violence and exclusion, revealing a stark contrast between India’s progressive urban identity and its deeply divided villages. The paper concludes with a somber reflection on the future, questioning the persistence of caste-based oppression despite constitutional ideals and societal progress.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “The early Rig Veda does not mention caste at all. The Purusha sukta , a later interpolation, mentions the four varnas.”
  • “The definitions of religion and caste as we know them were developed during the British period, in the 19 th century, “by elevating texts like Manusmriti to canonical status,” to quote Sanjoy Chakravorty.”
  • “The construction of social identities was done to serve the British government’s desire to create a single Hindu identity with a common law for easy governance.”

Works cited in this article

  1. Bandyopadhyay, Samaresh, Early Foreigners on Indian Caste System, Pilgrim Publishers, Calcutta, 1974.
  2. Bayly, Susan, “Caste, Society and Politics in India from the Eighteenth Century to the Modern Age”, The New Cambridge History of India, Cambridge University Press, 2001.
  3. Chakravorty, Sanjoy, The Truth About Us: The Politics of Information from Manu to Modi, Hachette India, 2019.
  4. Cornish, W.R., Census for the Madras Presidency, 1881.
  5. Jain, R. (ed.), McCrindle’s Ancient India as Described by Megasthenes and Arrian , Today & Tomorrow’s Printers & Publishers, New Delhi, 1972.

Discussed in this article

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 28
7–8Diverse Themes and Pan-India Perspectives in 28th JIHC IssueNanditha C. Krishna, G.B. Balaji, J. Sumathi, T. Pichulakshmi, H. Manikandan, Jothymani, Lata Ganapathy, S. N. Arya9–22Copper Mining and Metallurgy in Ancient India: Archaeological and Textual EvidenceMohammad Nazrul Bari9–22Copper Mining and Metallurgy in Ancient India: Archaeological and Textual EvidenceMohammad Nazrul Bari23–64From Jīnāgama to Jinabimba: The Evolution of Tīrtha in JainismMana Shah23–64From Jīnāgama to Jinabimba: The Evolution of Tīrtha in JainismMana Shah65–79Rare Vesara Vimana Architecture at Narasinganpettai TempleT. Sumitha65–79Rare Vesara Vimana Architecture at Narasinganpettai TempleT. Sumitha80–98Historical Overview of Ancient Traditional Tank Management Systems in IndiaS. S. Sundaram, G. Bhaskaran80–98Historical Overview of Ancient Traditional Tank Management Systems in IndiaS. S. Sundaram, G. Bhaskaran99–114New Findings in Earth/Water Iconography: A Carved-Wooden Sculpture from KeralaSeethal C P99–114New Findings in Earth/Water Iconography: A Carved-Wooden Sculpture from KeralaSeethal C P115–131Six Excavated Sites in Krishnagiri Region: Archaeological InsightsC. Chandrasekar115–131Six Excavated Sites in Krishnagiri Region: Archaeological InsightsC. Chandrasekar132–150Reconstructing the History of Cãhamãnas of Nadol: An Inscriptional StudyPriyanka Sharma132–150Reconstructing the History of Cãhamãnas of Nadol: An Inscriptional StudyPriyanka Sharma151–186Retrieving the Visual Imagery of the Original Bilpankeshwara Temple: The Dawn of Paramara ArtNikita Rathore151–186Retrieving the Visual Imagery of the Original Bilpankeshwara Temple: The Dawn of Paramara ArtNikita Rathore187–213Harihara-Ekapada Trimurti: Iconography and Conservation in Rāmagiri's Kalyāṇa-Nṛsiṃha TempleR.K.K. Rajarajan187–213Harihara-Ekapada Trimurti: Iconography and Conservation in Rāmagiri's Kalyāṇa-Nṛsiṃha TempleR.K.K. Rajarajan214–242Central and Western Indian Historical Testimonies on Early Medieval ŚaivismSurabhi Srivastava, Shakuntala Misra214–242Central and Western Indian Historical Testimonies on Early Medieval ŚaivismSurabhi Srivastava, Shakuntala Misra243–258Early Russian and Portuguese Trade Contacts with Peninsular India: 1469-1499Himen Das243–258Early Russian and Portuguese Trade Contacts with Peninsular India: 1469-1499Himen Das259–277Portugal's Pioneering Maritime Enterprise to India: Causes and MotivationsJames John259–277Portugal's Pioneering Maritime Enterprise to India: Causes and ConsequencesJames John278–297Bandel: A Lesser-Known Portuguese Settlement in Mughal BengalSubrata Roy278–297Bandel: A Lesser-Known Portuguese Settlement in Mughal BengalSubrata Roy298–311The Sepoy's Role in British India: Economic Security and Unity Against Colonial RuleSuman Kumar Verma298–311The Sepoy's Role in British India: Economic Security and Unity Against Colonial RuleSuman Kumar Verma312–334Khaksar Movement's Role in India's Freedom Struggle and Colonial Response (1930-1947)Muzafar Ahmad Dar312–334Khaksar Movement's Role in India's Freedom Struggle and Colonial Response (1930-1947)Muzafar Ahmad Dar335–341Coimbatore Working Class in Quit India Movement 1942V. C. Francis Xavier335–341Coimbatore Working Class in Quit India Movement 1942V. C. Francis Xavier342–367Women Labour in Colonial Malabar's Modern Industries: A StudyShapna K.P.342–367Women Labour in Colonial Malabar's Modern Industries: A StudyShapna K.P.368–378Historical Aspect of a Weaver’s Settlement in ChintadripetJ. Sumathi368–378Historical Aspect of a Weaver’s Settlement in ChintadripetJ. Sumathi379–402C.V. Kunjuraman's Role in Kerala's Social TransformationShaji A379–402C.V. Kunjuraman's Role in Kerala's Social TransformationShaji A403–433Women's Subordinate Status in Eighteenth-Century Oriya LiteratureSankarsan Malik403–433Women in Eighteenth-Century Oriya Literature: Subordination and Patriarchal NormsSankarsan Malik434–447Gandhi's Environmental Philosophy and Sustainable DevelopmentS. Babu434–447Gandhi's Environmental Philosophy and Sustainable DevelopmentS. Babu448–465Telugu Songs, Theatre, and Cinema in South India's Freedom StruggleSrinath Sriperumbudur448–465Telugu Songs, Theatre, and Cinema in South India's Freedom StruggleSrinath Sriperumbudur466–486Rice, Sugarcane, and India's Role in Global PropagationParvathy Menon466–486Rice, Sugarcane, and India's Role in Global PropagationParvathy Menon487–514Traditional Landforms and Land Use Changes in North Eastern IndiaG. Srinivasan487–514Traditional Land Forms and Changing Land Use Patterns in Northeast IndiaG. Srinivasan515–520Caste System's Historical Flexibility and British ImpactNanditha C. Krishna515–520Caste System's Enduring Grip: Historical Roots and British ReinforcementNanditha C. KrishnaCurrent article521–525India That Is Bharat: Coloniality, Civilisation, and ConstitutionJ. Sai Deepak521–525India That Is Bharat: Coloniality, Civilisation, and ConstitutionJ. Sai Deepak526–532Rgveda's Historical Context: Geography, Society, and Harappan ConnectionsR. N. Nandi526–532Rgveda's Historical Context: Geography, Society, and Harappan ConnectionsR. N. Nandi

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by Nanditha C. Krishna

All articles →
Journal of Indian History and Culture

Sarasvatī: From River to Goddess in Vedic Culture

By Nanditha C. Krishna

June 2023
Journal of Indian History and Culture

JIHC June 2023: New Peer Review Process, Diverse Themes, and Contributor Guidelines

By Nanditha C. Krishna, Kamala Gopalan, Yamini Anish Shah, G.B. Balaji, J. Sumathi

June 2023
Journal of Indian History and Culture

India: The Mother of Democracy - Historical Roots and Enduring Values

By Nanditha C. Krishna, G.B. Balaji, Raghuvendra Tanwar, Umesh Ashok Kadam, Vasant Shinde, Kapil Kapoor, Arvind P Jamkhedkar, Prasad Joshi, Himanshu Roy, Harihar Panda, Jigar Mohammad

December 2022
Journal of Indian History and Culture

Agni's Evolution in Vedic Iconography and Art

By Nanditha C. Krishna

December 2022

Continue reading

Related articles

The Jaina Gazette

Backward Classes in the Dekkan

October 1907
Jinamanjari

Jainism and the Western World

By Hermann Jacobi, Peter Flügel

1998
Journal of Indian History and Culture

Caste System's Historical Flexibility and British Impact

By Nanditha C. Krishna

December 2021
Journal of Indian History and Culture

The Microphone Men: How Orators Shaped Modern India

By Priyadarshi Dutt

June 2022
Journal of Indian History and Culture

Nationalist Movement in South India: Vizagapatam District's Role in India's Freedom Struggle

By M. S. R. Anjaneyulu

September 2005