Skip to content
Browse articles

Notes and Queries

By Dineshchandra Sircar

Vol. 24 · No. 1March - 1948pp. 71–79English

Summary

The “Notes and Queries” section comprises several short articles addressing unresolved questions in early Indian history and epigraphy. One note reports the discovery of a clay seal at Basarh inscribed with the name Ghaṭotkacagupta and discusses whether this little‑known prince actually ruled or was merely a royal heir. Scholars differ on the identification: some argue that Ghaṭotkacagupta was a son or grandson of the Gupta emperor Kumāragupta and may have reigned briefly; others point out that the seal’s paleography and context are ambiguous, and no independent evidence of his rule survives. Another article reviews various names that appear on late Gupta coins and seals – Vainya‑gupta, Bhānu‑gupta, Jaya‑gupta and others – and notes that they cannot be securely placed in the standard genealogy. The authors suggest that during the decline of the Gupta Empire several princes may have ruled regional domains simultaneously, which would explain the profusion of unfamiliar names. A further note evaluates the theory that Govinda‑gupta succeeded Candragupta II as imperial king. Some inscriptions call Govinda‑gupta a mahārājādhirāja and describe him as “honoured by tributary kings,” but the article emphasises that these phrases may be honorific and that no dated records of his reign exist. The writer concludes that Govinda‑gupta was probably a powerful prince who administered a province rather than an emperor and cautions against lengthening the imperial succession without firm evidence. Collectively, the notes emphasise how fragmentary epigraphic data complicate the reconstruction of Gupta genealogy. They illustrate the need for caution when assigning imperial titles to individuals based on single seals or inscriptions and encourage scholars to consider the possibility of overlapping regional rulers during the empire’s decline.

AI-assisted summary, not yet checked. Consult the original PDF before citing.

Conclusion

The “Notes and Queries” highlight how scant inscriptions and seals can both illuminate and complicate early Indian chronology. By analysing the Basarh seal of Ghaṭotkacagupta, discussing enigmatic names like Vainya‑gupta and Bhānu‑gupta and revisiting the question of Govinda‑gupta’s kingship, the contributors show that the late Gupta period may have been characterised by multiple short‑lived rulers governing different regions. The section underscores the need for critical examination of epigraphic evidence and warns against drawing sweeping conclusions from isolated discoveries.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “A seal of $i-Ghaotkacagupta (without any royal title) was discovered at Basarh {anciene Vaisalt) in the Muzaffarpur District of North Bihar along with chose of Mahadevi Dhruvasvamini (Dhruvadevi) queen of Candragupta II, and of her son Mabaraja Govindagupta.”
  • “It therefore seems to me coo much to claim chat “there is every reason to conclude that Ghatotkacagupta of the coin, seal and inscfiption is one, and he succeeded Kumaragupta } and preceded Skandagupta, and he can now he safely placed in the Gupta chronology between them.””
  • “The suggestion that Govindagupta occupied the Gupta - imperial throne in 413-15 A.D, should therefore be regarded as a guess as yet unsupported by any definite evidence.”

Works cited in this article

  1. Proc. LH.C., 1946, pp. 78-82.
  2. H.Q., MARCH, 1948
  3. Sel. Ins., I, pp. 418-25
  4. Sel. /ns., p. 327
  5. JHQ., XXIII, pp. 156-59

Discussed in this article

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by Dineshchandra Sircar

All articles →
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Some Unpublished Jaina Sculptures of Ganesa from the Western India

By Dineshchandra Sircar

Jan - 1975
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Mahavira’s Theory of Samatva Yoga — a Psycho-Analytical Approach

By Dineshchandra Sircar

Jan - 1975
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Jaina Temples in East Bengal in the Seventeenth Century

By Dineshchandra Sircar

Jan - 1975
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Date of the Periplus

By Dineshchandra Sircar

March and June 1963

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

Epigraphical Notes

By Dineshchandra Sircar

June & September 1960