Skip to content
Browse articles

Reviews

By Jitendra Nath Banerjee

Vol. 8 · No. 3September - 1932pp. 624–631English

Summary

The review section opens with an assessment of H. R. Rangaswamy Iyengar’s edition of Dignāga’s Pramāṇasamuccaya, an important text of Buddhist logic. The reviewer summarises Dignāga’s role as the father of the medieval school of Indian logic and notes that the Sanskrit original of his work is lost. Iyengar has reconstructed the first chapter from Tibetan translations and commentaries, adding extracts from Jñānendra­buddhi’s viśālāmalavatī. The reviewer praises the effort but suggests corrections to some restored readings and notes that future editions should discuss alternative textual variants. A second notice reviews V. S. Bendrey’s edition of Keshav Paṇḍit’s Rajaram‑caritam, a contemporary Marathi narrative of Chatrapati Rajaram’s flight to Jinji, and H. N. Sinha’s Rise of the Peshwas, a textbook that surveys Maratha history and will serve university students. A third review examines Kanniayalal Vakil’s Rock‑cut Temples around Bombay, which describes the cave shrines of Elephanta, Jogeshwari, Kanheri and Mandapeshwar. The reviewer highlights Vakil’s emphasis on interpreting the artistic motifs rather than merely cataloguing them and applauds the plates and drawings.

AI-generated summary, automatically checked against the article text.

Conclusion

Collectively, the reviews acknowledge valuable contributions to the study of Buddhist logic, Maratha history and Indian art. They urge editors to pay greater attention to textual variants and commend works that combine scholarly rigour with accessible presentation.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “Diinags is rightly regirded ૩ tbe father of the medimval school of Indian Logic.”
  • “Unfortunately his works છાં which the most important is 110 Pramanasamuccaya are now uot extant in original Sanskrit excepting some fragments or passages referred 10 or quoted in different books, such as the Nyayavartithe of Uddyotakara, Tatpuryatita of Vicaspati-wisdra, Mimamsaflokavarttiba-itha of Parthasirathimisra, Tattvasam.-grahapaitjiké of Eamalaéila, and 80 on.”
  • “The cave shrines at Klephanta, શહ these are sifuated in and near the city, very anppropriately called the ‘Gate of Indie’, are among the most frequently visited and described monuments of India.”

Works cited in this article

  1. Pramanasamuccaya
  2. Nyayavartithe of Uddyotakara
  3. Tatpuryatita of Vicaspati-wisdra
  4. Mimamsaflokavarttiba-itha of Parthasirathimisra
  5. Tattvasam.-grahapaitjiké of Eamalaéila

Discussed in this article

People

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 8 · No. 3
425–441Some Problems of Indian PhilosophyArthur Berriedale Keith442–448The Eastern Cālukyas (II) — Kubja‑ViṣṇuvardhanaDhirendra Chandra Ganguly449–461RaziyyaNirode Bhusan Roy462–465Mahanama in the Pali LiteratureB. Siddhartha466–479Was Candragupta low‑born?Harit Krishna Deb480–499Hindu Theatre: An interpretation of Bharata’s second AdhyayaD. R. Mankad500–508Krishna and JarasandhaSadashiva L. Katre509–520Some Problems of Sāṅkhya Philosophy and Sāṅkhya LiteratureKali Pada Bhattacharya521–534Some Janapadas of Ancient RāḍhāPrabodh Chandra Sengupta535–541The Prince of Wales Museum grant of Mahāsāmanta IndrakēśīB. C. S. Sharma542–548Two new lists of KalāsChintaharan Chakravarti549–564Ancient coins found in Pāñcāla, Ayodhyā, Kauśāmbī and Mathurā — a StudyCharu Chandra Das Gupta565–570The Jaina School of Astronomy (Part II) - The Theory of the two SunsSukumar Ranjan Das571–582Mir Qasim at MonghyrNandlal Chatterji583–588Fire‑Arms in Ancient India (Part III)Jogesh Chandra Roy589–590Miscellany – A Note on a passage in the Śatapatha BrāhmaṇaS. N. Pradhan591–594Miscellany – Notes on Aśoka RescriptsSailendra Nath Mitra595–599Miscellany – Kapardaka PurāṇaSurendra Kishore Chakraborty600–605Some Problems of Pre‑Buddhist History and ChronologyHem Chandra Raychaudhuri606–609Uvvata on Syllabication of ConsonantsV. Venkatarama Sharma610–610The Besnagar Inscription of HeliodorosVidhushekhara Bhattacharya611–614Identity of Vidyaranya and MadhavacaryaK. Markandeya Sharma615–617Nalanda Stone Inscription of Yaśovarmadeva – A RejoinderA. K. Mrityunjayam618–623Cauhān Mahārājas of Pāṭnā State (Mahākosala)L. P. Pandeya Sharma624–631ReviewsJitendra Nath BanerjeeCurrent article632–638Select Contents of Oriental Journals639–641Bibliographical Notes

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by Jitendra Nath Banerjee

All articles →
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Review: Rgyan-Drug Mchog-Gnyis

By Jitendra Nath Banerjee

December - 1961
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Myths explaining some alien traits of the North-Indian Sun-icons

By Jitendra Nath Banerjee

March - 1952
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Srimad Bhagavata—Place of its Origin

By Jitendra Nath Banerjee

June - 1951
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Schools of Buddhism in Early Indian Inscriptions

By Jitendra Nath Banerjee

December - 1948

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

Reviews

By Satkari Mookherjree, U. N. Ghoshal, Batakrishna Ghosh, Sri Ram Sharma, R. N. Sarkar

Dec-37
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Reviews

By U. N. Ghoshal

September - 1936
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review: Uttaradhyayana Sutra

By V. G. Nair

July - 1978
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Sri Mahavir Jaina Vidyalaya Golden Jubilee Volume (Review)

July 1970
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review

By Suniti Kumar Chatterji

Jul-73