Skip to content
Browse articles

Bodhisattva Pratimoksa Sutra

By Nalinaksha Dutt

Vol. 7 · No. 2June - 1931pp. 259–286English, Sanskrit
Hinayana Mahayana Comparison

Summary

The “Bodhisattva‑Pratimoksa Sūtra” article surveys newly discovered manuscripts of Buddhist monastic disciplinary texts and assesses their implications for understanding the development of the Prātimokṣa. The Prātimokṣa forms the backbone of monastic discipline, listing the rules monks and nuns must follow. For many years scholars had access only to the Pāli Patimokkha of the Theravādins, but the early twentieth century saw the discovery of Sanskrit manuscripts belonging to the Sarvāstivādins and other schools. These fragments, found in Kucha and Turfan by French and German expeditions, were edited by E. Huber, Sylvain Lévi, Przyluski, La Vallée Poussin and Ernst Waldschmidt. They included the Pratimokṣa‑sūtra itself, associated Karmavācanā (procedural texts) and portions of the Bhikṣuṇī‑Pratimokṣa and Bhikṣuṇī‑Vibhanga. Comparative study of the Sanskrit texts with Chinese and Tibetan translations demonstrates that multiple redactions existed and that the Sarvāstivādin recension differed from the Theravādin Patimokkha. The article reviews scholarly debates on whether the Pratimokṣa originated in Magadhi, Pāli or a hybrid Sanskrit and discusses how the language of the fragments—archaic Buddhist Sanskrit—supports the hypothesis that the earliest disciplinary texts were composed in a dialect intermediate between Magadhi and classical Sanskrit. The author provides transliterations of a recently examined leaf containing doctrinal exposition on the emptiness of mind (śūnyatā) that appears to be part of a Bodhisattva Prātimokṣa. He notes that the manuscript may belong to a later period or to a Mahāyāna school since it introduces bodhisattva vows alongside monastic rules. The text expounds on how mind is devoid of inherent self and how ultimate reality transcends aggregates and sense bases. The article concludes that the growing corpus of Pratimokṣa fragments allows scholars to reconstruct early monastic rules, trace the evolution of disciplinary literature among different schools, and explore the transition from monastic precepts to bodhisattva ethics.

AI-generated summary, automatically checked against the article text.

Conclusion

By collating newly found Sanskrit Pratimokṣa manuscripts with Pāli, Chinese and Tibetan versions, the article demonstrates that monastic disciplinary literature existed in multiple recensions and languages. These discoveries challenge the assumption that the Pāli Patimokkha is the sole representative of early Buddhist discipline and show that Sanskrit schools developed their own Pratimokṣa traditions. The leaf transliteration illustrating bodhisattva doctrine suggests a link between monastic and Mahāyāna ethics. Overall, the study underscores the value of manuscript finds from Central Asia for reconstructing the textual history of Buddhist vinaya.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “The Pritimokgasatra forms the keystone of the disciplinary literature of the DBuddhists.”
  • “It is this additional ritual that gives a Mahayinic or Mahdyina-Tintric garb to the Hinayanic ceremony.”

Works cited in this article

  1. Nouveaux fragments de la collection Stein.
  2. Sylvain Lévi, /A, 1913 ; Hoernle, Manuscript Remains of Buddhist Literature in Fastern Turkestam, pp. 73-5.
  3. Bendall, Catalogue of the Buddhist Sanskrit Manuscripts

Discussed in this article

People

Places

  • Koutcha
  • Qyzil

Texts & works

  • Bodhisattva Pratimoksa Sutra
  • Bodkisattva-Pratimoksa-stitra
  • Kammavacam
  • Kriyisangrakhapatijika
  • Kudrglinirghitama

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 7 · No. 2
214–244Origin of the Bell-CapitalAchyuta Kumar Mitra245–253Topography in the PuranasSashi Bhusan Chaudhuri253–258Dvaidhibhava in the KautiliyaNarendra Nath Law259–286Bodhisattva Pratimoksa SutraNalinaksha DuttCurrent article287–300The First Saka of CitodSubimal Chandra Datta301–308Mandana, Suresvara and Bhavabhuti : The Problem of their IdentityDinesh Chandra Bhattacharya309–318Some Notes on Skanda-KarttikeyaManmatha Mukhopadhyay319–330Kulasekhara of KeralaK. Rama Pisharoti331–333A Surya Icon from a Dasavatara Temple, PaganNiharranjan Roy334–342Vilvamangalam SvamiyarsA. Govinda Warrier343–358Early Visnuism and Narayaniya WorshipMrinal Das Gupta359–362Ganga in Ceylon and IndiaJ. C. De362–364An Early Supporter of ShivajiJadunath Sarkar365–366The Webbed Finger of BuddhaAnanda Kentish Coomaraswamy367–370A Few Evidences on the Age of the KathavatthuDwijendra Lal Barua370–371The Age of the Visnu PuranaV. R. Ramachandra Dikshitar371–376More on ManimekhalaSylvain Levi377–379Derivation of PaliS. V. Viswanatha380–383Problems of the NatyasastraHarihara V. Trivedi384–388Technical Terms in the Hindu Revenue SystemU. N. Ghoshal389–410The English Translation of the KautiliyaNarendra Nath Law410–412An Inscription dated in the Reign of Emperor Muhammad ShahDineshchandra Sircar412–412Candasutinam in the Nanaghat Cave InscriptionDineshchandra Sircar413–418The BhagavrttiKshitish Chandra Chatterjee418–419The Authorship of the AnunyasaKshitish Chandra Chatterjee420–427ReviewsAnanda Kentish Coomaraswamy, Subimal Chandra Datta428–432Select Contents of Oriental Journals433–434Bibliographical Notes

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by Nalinaksha Dutt

All articles →
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Review: Histoire du Bouddhisme Indien des Origines à l'ère Saka

By Nalinaksha Dutt

March - 1960
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Survival of the Paippalada Atharvaveda in Eastern India

By Nalinaksha Dutt

March - 1960
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Buddhism in Chinese History

By Nalinaksha Dutt

March - 1959
The Indian Historical Quarterly

The Second Buddhist Council

By Nalinaksha Dutt

March - 1959

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

Nirvana according to the Tibetan Tradition

By Eugéne Obermiller

June - 1934
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Doctrine of Kāya in Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna

By Nalinaksha Dutt

September - 1929