Skip to content
Browse articles

Some Notes on the Transmission of the Ayaranga-sutta

By Colette Caillat

Vol. 201996pp. 12–15English

Summary

Colette Caillat summarises observations on the transmission of the Jain canonical text Ayaranga‑sutta. She notes that the scripture now consists of two srutaskandhas; the first was originally the true Acaranga and contained nine adhyayanas, one of which has been lost. The second is a collection of appendices whose culas have partly become separate treatises. European scholars and Jain editors like Muni Jambuvijaya observed that the text’s transmission has suffered disruptions and that variants are especially pronounced in the second srutaskandha. Caillat compares the Curni and Vrtti traditions: the older Curni preserves a simpler version while the Vrtti contains elaborate expansions. She illustrates differences in length, order and wording, especially in the Bhavana section where passages from other texts have been inserted. Examples show accumulation of synonyms and poetic comparatives, indicating scribal embellishment. Caillat argues that these variants reflect deliberate expansions and rearrangements rather than random errors. She emphasises that Jain acaryas have long engaged in philological work and that modern scholars must continue this critical tradition with respect for sacred texts.

AI-generated summary, automatically checked against the article text.

Conclusion

Caillat concludes that the Ayaranga‑sutta’s transmission reflects centuries of textual evolution. Variants arise from deliberate expansions, abridgements and reorganisations across different traditions. Distinguishing the simpler Curni version from the more ornate Vrtti helps reconstruct the history of the Jain canon and underscores the importance of sustained philological scrutiny.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “Nevertheless, curiously enough, the transmission of this sacred sutra appears to have suffered from many disruptions a situation which had not escaped the attention of the' European scholars H. Jacobi and W. Schubring, and which again is detailed by Muni Jambuvijaya.”
  • “Curiously, though the text of the first srutaskandha is often very difficult to follow, is (in the words of Jacobi) 'like a sermon made up of quotations...., fragments of verses and whole verses which are liberally interspersed in the prose text', the two versions differ only slightly.”
  • “The tradition of readings followed by the author of the Cumi is much older and better than the one followed by the author of the V/tti.”

Works cited in this article

  1. Sramana 6.4 [1958]
  2. Jainagama Svadhyaya, Ahmedabad 1991
  3. JAS 1, Nandisuttam and Anuogaddaraim, Editors Muni Punyavijaya, Pt. Dalsukh Malvania, Pt. Amritlal Mohanlal Bhojak, Bombay 1968
  4. Proceedings of the International Conference organized in Paris from 25th to 27th January 1996 as a commemoration of the birth centenary of the French Indologist Louis Renou

Discussed in this article

People

Texts & works

Dynasties, sects & groups

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 20
1–11Natyasastra, Sanskrit Drama and Its TheatreRadhavallabh Tripathi12–15Some Notes on the Transmission of the Ayaranga-suttaColette CaillatCurrent article16–23Middle Indic tuvatta-Herman Tieken24–31Pustimargi Poetry in Gujarati – The Lord of Braj Travelled to Gujarat TwiceMallison32–42Self‑Luminosity of Consciousness in Advaita Vedanta as explained in the NyayamakarandaRabindra Kumar Panda43–61'Niravasita' (Panini 2.4.10)M. Srimannarayana Murti62–66Candralekhavijaya Prakarana: A Discovery of an Island of Dramatic ExcellenceVijay Pandya67–72Heretical Conception of Universe and Jain Critique as depicted in the Sutrakrtanga Commentary of SilankaCh. Lalitha73–76Kalinjar Fort: The Time Winner Ancientmost Fort of IndiaDinesh Chandra Bhattacharya77–91Variants from Venisamhara and the Kavyaprakasa of MammataJagruti S. Pandya92–99Alamkara‑DappanaHarivallabh Chunilal Bhayani100–108Heredity and EnvironmentRatanlal Jain109–122સમ્મતાકાર : એક અપ્રસિદ્ધ વૈયાકરણNilanjana S. Shah123–127વડનગરનો સમ્મતિય સંઘારામRatilal N. Mehta, Munindra Vishwa Joshi, Ratilal Satya Bhavsar128–131અમદાવાદની કેટલીક ઉમા-મહેશ્વરની યુગલ પ્રતિમાઓRambhai Thakar Savaliya, Munindra Vishwa Joshi132–133કતિપય ધાતુમય જિન-પ્રતિમાના અભિલેખMadhusudan Dhanki, Lakshmanbhai Bhojak134–144જૈન પુરાણો પર એક દૃષ્ટિપાતKantilal R. Dave145–146ભીમદેવ બીજાના વિશ્વ સં. ૧૨૬૩ના તામ્રપત્રમાં મળતા કેટલાક શબ્દો પર નોંધHarivallabh Chunilal Bhayani147–166રાજસારકૃત પુંડરીક-કુંડરીક-સંધિKalpana Kanubhai Sheth167–190Untitled articleNarayan M. Kansara191–212ReviewsNarayan M. Kansara

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by Colette Caillat

All articles →
Sambodhi

Jaina studies in Europe

By Colette Caillat

1998-1999
Sambodhi

Some Notes On The Transmission Of The Ayarangasutta

By Colette Caillat

1997-98
Sambodhi

The Offering of Distichs (Doha-pahuda)

By Colette Caillat

1976