Skip to content
Browse articles

Reviews

By Narayan M. Kansara

Vol. 211997-98pp. 138–163English

Summary

This section of the volume, compiled by N.M. Kansara, contains detailed reviews of several recent publications in Indological studies. The first review evaluates the Āyāraṅga Word Index and Reverse Word Index and the Suyagaḍa Word Index and Reverse Word Index compiled by Morichi Yamazaki and Yumi Ousaka. Kansara summarises the editors’ methods of producing pada indices for early Jain Āgamic texts, comments on the value of such tools for researchers, and notes areas where the compilers might refine their approach. He stresses the importance of basing indices on critical editions and the need to consider Prakrit variants. The section then reviews Śivasvāmin’s “Kapphiṇābhyudaya,” a Sanskrit poem edited by Gauri Shankar with Romanised cantos contributed by Michael Hahn. The reviewer situates the poem within the literary revival of 9th‑century Kashmir, praises Śivasvāmin’s imagination and technical skill, and provides context for the story of King Kapphiṇa. Other reviews discuss works on linguistic studies, Buddhist philosophy, and editions of Jain texts. For each book, Kansara outlines the main arguments, assesses editorial quality and comments on the contribution to its field. He occasionally notes shortcomings such as typographical errors, inadequate introductions or lack of reference to contemporary scholarship. The reviews demonstrate Kansara’s wide reading and his commitment to improving scholarly standards. Taken together, this section serves as a guide for readers seeking reliable secondary literature and reveals the vitality of research on Indian languages, literature and religion during the mid‑1990s.

AI-assisted summary, not yet checked. Consult the original PDF before citing.

Conclusion

The review section curated by N.M. Kansara functions as both critique and appreciation of recent Indological publications. By summarising and evaluating a diverse set of works, Kansara provides guidance for scholars while encouraging higher editorial standards. His assessments reveal the growing sophistication of textual tools and highlight the continued relevance of classical literature in contemporary research.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “Both Yamazaki and Ousaka have so far published similar pada index and reverse pada index to the following five early Jaina Agamic texts, viz., Dasaveyalia, Isibhaiyaim, Uttarajjhaya, Ayaranga and Siiyagada, by doing the metrical and the grammatical analysis with the help of computor.”
  • “For the Ayaranga word and reverse word Index they have utilised 85 the basic text Schubring’s critical edition, while for that of the Siiyagada they have based it on P. L. Vaidya’s edition.”
  • “All the same, the effort they have put in their research monographs so far fully deserves to be congratuated in view of the valuable assistance it is envisioned to provide to researchers in the field of Prakrit and Agamic Jainological studies.”

Works cited in this article

  1. AYARANGA WORD INDEX AND REVERSE WORD INDEX, Yamazaki, Morichi and Ousaka, Yumi - Philologica Asiatica Monograph series 8, The Chuo Academic Research Institute, Tokyo, 1996, pp. ii + 105.
  2. SUYAGADA WORD INDEX AND REVERSE WORD INDEX, Yamazaki, Morichi and Ousaka, Yumi - Philologica Asiatica Monograph Series 9, The Chuo Academic Research Institute, Tokyo, 1996, pp. ii + 121.
  3. SIVASVAMIN’S KAPPHINABHYUDAYA OR EXALTATION OF KING KAPPHINA, edited by Gauri Shankar, with an Appendix and Romanized Version of Cantos I-VIII and XIX by Michael Hahn, Aditya Prakashan, New Delhi, 1989, pp. + 165
  4. NIRAYAVALIYA-SUYAKKHANDHA UVANGAS 8-12 OF THE JAIN CANON, Delue, Jozef - with Introduction, Text-edition and Notes, translated from the Dutch by J. W. de Jong and Royce Wiles, The Chuo Academic Research Institute, Tokyo, 1996, pp. 86.
  5. Kavyadarsa

Discussed in this article

People

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 21
1–4Some Notes On The Transmission Of The AyarangasuttaColette Caillat5–34Kumarasambhava As Critically Examined by Sanskrit AlamkarikasArpita G. Patel35–45Trade Relations of India With Africa Upto 14th Century A. D.Ravindranath Vaman Ramdas46–48Amari Ghosana-no Dastaveja (Proclamation of non-killing of animals)Shridhar Andhare49–57Water Treatment in the AtharvavedaSubhash Chandra Dash58–60Relations Between the Calukyas of Gujarat With the Bhatis of JaisalmerRam Vallabh Somani61–74Bharata - Bahubali - Mahakavya : A CritiqueSatyavrat Verma75–77On the Semantic Aspect of Some Types of Gujarati OnomatopoeiasHarivallabh Chunilal Bhayani78–84Prakrit Narrative Literature And Contribution of Vardhamanasiiri (1060-1120 A.D.) to itNarayan M. Kansara85–95Alamkara-DappanaHarivallabh Chunilal Bhayani96–102ધુવસેન પહેલાનું તામ્રપત્ર (વી.สં. ૨૦૬)103–104પાશુપતાચાર્ય મેઘરાશિનું તામ્રપત્રLakshmanbhai Bhojak105–116ગુજરાતના પ્રસિદ્ધ હસ્તલિખિત- ગ્રંથભંડારોBharti Shelat, Rambhai Thakar Savaliya117–131સાહિત્યમીમાંસામાં વિચારાયેલું રસસ્વરૂપParul N. Mankad132–137જૈન આચાર્યોના મતે કવિનું સ્વરૂપ અને પ્રકારોAmbalal Prajapati138–163ReviewsNarayan M. KansaraCurrent article164–179Brief NoticesNarayan M. Kansara180–182'અવલોકન'Jayant Prem Thaker183–183Acknowledgements184–184L. D. Series Recent Publications185–185Our Contributors186–188Seminar on Ardhamagadhi Jain Agama LiteratureKanjibhai M. Patel

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by Narayan M. Kansara

All articles →
Sambodhi

The Moral Codes of the Swaminarayanism and of the Jainism: A Comparative Study

By Narayan M. Kansara

2014
Sambodhi

Ṛṣidattacaritra Saṃgraha

By Narayan M. Kansara

2012
Sambodhi

The Karma Doctrine in the Swaminarayan Tradition

By Narayan M. Kansara

2003
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Jainism, Mahavira, Buddha and Nirvana

By Narayan M. Kansara

July - 2001