Skip to content
Browse articles

Growth of Not-Man in Buddhism

By C. A. F. Rhys Davids

Vol. 4 · No. 3September - 1928pp. 406–416English

Summary

The article "Growth of Not-Man in Buddhism" explores the evolution of spiritual concepts in Indian thought, particularly the shift from emphasizing the "man-in-man" (the inner spiritual self) to the Buddhist doctrine of "not-self" (anatta). Initially, Indian teachers focused on the "man-in-man" as the ultimate reality, equating the individual self (atman) with the divine. However, the rise of the Sankhya school introduced a new analysis of human consciousness, distinguishing between the physical body, the thinking mind, and the self (purusha). This analytical approach questioned the permanence of the self, suggesting that even the mind, composed of transient mental processes, could not fully encapsulate the eternal self. Over time, the influence of Sankhya led to debates about the nature of the self and its relationship with the imperishable reality (Brahman). Some reform movements prioritized asceticism and monasticism, devaluing worldly life and emphasizing escape from suffering. This shift eventually influenced Buddhist thought, where the concept of "not-self" gained prominence. The article argues that the original teachings of the Buddha, initially called "Sakyan" or "Sakyan," were later distorted by monastic elaborations, which misrepresented the Buddha's emphasis on ethical living and gradual spiritual growth. The author critiques modern scholarship for either accepting monastic interpretations at face value or dismissing the possibility of recovering the Buddha's original, accessible teachings for the laity. The article calls for a re-examination of early Buddhist texts to better understand the evolution of "not-man" as a central doctrine.

AI-assisted summary, not yet checked. Consult the original PDF before citing.

Conclusion

The analysis of the "Not-Man" in Buddhism reveals a profound shift in Indian spiritual thought, emphasizing the inner self over the physical and ritualistic aspects of human existence. This intellectual movement, rooted in the Sankhya school's dissociation of the self from the body and mind, redefined the pursuit of spiritual unity with the ultimate reality. By challenging the Brahmanical orthodoxy and prioritizing the individual's inner consciousness, this framework not only influenced later Vedantic synthesis but also laid the groundwork for a more introspective and analytical approach to liberation. The tension between the imperishable self and the transient mind highlighted the limitations of ritualistic practices, ultimately fostering a deeper emphasis on ethical living and the gradual realization of the self's identity with the absolute. This transformation underscores Buddhism's enduring contribution to the conceptualization of the self and its role in transcending worldly impermanence.

Key passages

Chosen by AI from the article's text. Each one is checked word for word against the text before it is shown.

  • “But there came & day when India wavered in 119: vision. This was when she began to consider man in & new way of analysis, man not only as having body, not only as thinker and doer, but as ‘having”
  • “The perfect man, with consummation into That cut off, dwindled into a ‘worthiness,’ to be attained in earth-conditions—a perfection, to us, clearly unobtainable in that it was limited by its conditions.”

Works cited in this article

  1. Maitri Up.
  2. Vibhajjavadins
  3. Buddhist Psychology, 2nd, ed., London, 1924, ch, xiii
  4. Indian Buddhism (1896), p. 50.
  5. DBriggs' Ferishta, vol, 11, p. 511

Discussed in this article

People

Places

Texts & works

  • Chandogya
  • Brhadarapyeka
  • Aitareya Upanigads

Dynasties, sects & groups

AI guide

Discuss this record

Ask about the article, its topics, issue context, selected passages, or reading strategy.

Start with the record

I can unpack the summary, turn it into study questions, explain a selected passage, or compare it with the other articles in this issue.

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Same author

More by C. A. F. Rhys Davids

All articles →
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Review – Dialogues of the Buddha

By C. A. F. Rhys Davids

December - 1945
The Indian Historical Quarterly

More about Dhyana

By C. A. F. Rhys Davids

June - 1940
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Going Far or Going Beyond

By C. A. F. Rhys Davids

June - 1938
The Indian Historical Quarterly

The Relations between Early Buddhism and Brahmanism

By C. A. F. Rhys Davids

June - 1934